Mike Boyle: Understanding and Training Hip Flexion
A recent post on the forums at StrengthCoach.com made me realize that a short answer to a complicated question doesn’t often work. A few of my readers seemed to think that all of the recent talk about a weak or an under-active psoas muscle might just be people being trendy.
I, for one, strongly disagree.
My increased knowledge of the biomechanics of hip flexion is one of the most valuable things that I have learned in the past five years. The problem with understanding hip flexion, in general, and the psoas muscle, in particular, is that we use the term hip flexor as a generic term to apply to five muscles, four of which have distinctly different leverage positions from the other one.
Like most of us in the profession, I did not previously make any distinction among members of the hip flexor group. All of the hip flexor muscles seemed to work together to flex the hip and that, at the time, was enough for me. However, my recent reading into the work of physical therapist Shirley Sahrmann has changed my thinking about hip flexors, as it has about many other muscle groups.
The wisdom that Sahrmann shares in her book Diagnosis and Treatment of Movement Impairment Syndromes explains many of the injury riddles of the Strength and Conditioning field, particularly the “hip flexor pull” or “quad pull.” The key to understanding the motion of hip flexion comes from looking at the anatomical leverages of the different muscles involved. There are five muscles that are capable of assisting in hip flexion:
tensor fasciae latae (TFL),
rectus femoris (distinct in that it is both a member of the quadriceps group and a hip flexor),
As previously mentioned three of these muscles possess something in common, two are distinctly different. Not to be cliché, but the key is in the differences, not the similarities.
The TFL, rectus femoris and sartorius, all have insertion at the iliac crest. This means that all of these muscles are capable of hip flexion up to the level of the hip. This is simply a function of the principles of mechanical leverage.
The psoas and the iliacus are different. The psoas has its origin on the entire lumbar spine, the iliacus on the posterior of the ilium. Their origins creates two distinct differences.
1) The psoas acts directly on the spine. Possibly as a stabilizer for the iliacus and possibly as a flexor.
2) The psoas and the iliacus are the only hip flexors capable of bringing the hip above ninety degrees.
In the case of a weak or under-active psoas or iliacus, the femur may move above the level of the hip but it is not from the action of the psoas and iliacus but rather from the momentum created by the other three hip flexors. With this knowledge in hand, I believe that our knowledge of back pain, “hip flexor strains,” and ‘quad pulls” is drastically expanded. Before we discuss specific injuries let’s first look at how to assess the function of the psoas and iliacus.
Sahrmann’s test is simple. In single-leg stance, pull one knee to the chest and release. Inability to keep the knee above ninety degrees for 10–15 seconds indicates a weak psoas or a weak iliacus.
— a cramp at the iliac crest in the region of the TFL,
— an immediate backward lean to compensate,
— a large pelvic shift to the right or left,
— a quick drop from the top with a “catch” at the ninety-degree point.
Any/all of these will indicate that the client or athlete is attempting to compensate for the weak or under-active muscles. The TFL cramp is a classic illustration of synergistic dominance. A muscle cramps when attempting to shorten in a disadvantageous position.
With the hip flexed above ninety, the TFL is already shortened and unable to produce the necessary force to hold in a position of poor leverage. The attempt results in cramping, much like a hamstring cramp in bridging when the glutes are under-active. The same effects are often seen when attempting hanging knee ups (an exercise we almost never do, as it teaches compensation), except the cramp or strain is in the rectus femoris.
If the tester is concerned that the subject is a skilled compensator, Strength and Conditioning coach Karen Wood developed a better test that also has become our favorite psoas/iliacus exercise:
Have the client or athlete stand with one foot on a plyo box (24″ works well for most) that places the knee above the hip. With the hands overhead or behind the head, attempt to lift the foot off the box and hold for five seconds. Inability to lift and hold is indicative of a weak psoas and or iliacus. To add resistance and use this test as an exercise, lateral resistors or bands can be used to increase the difficulty of the isometric. It is important to note that any test of the psoas originating from below the hip is inherently invalid, as the iliac-originated hip flexors are now at a leverage advantage.
Understanding the unique functional contributions of the psoas and iliacus illustrates how a weak or under-active muscle can be a factor in both back pain and in quadriceps strains. With back pain, inability to flex the hip past ninety degrees will often cause many clients or athletes to flex the lumbar spine to give the illusion of flexing the hips. Watch how many of your clients or athletes will immediately flex the lumbar spine when asked to bring the knee to the chest. There is a clear distinction between bringing the knee to the chest and bringing the chest to the knee. Attempting to bring the knee toward the chest and above the level of the hip forces the athlete or client to use, or attempt to use, the psoas and iliacus. If they are unable to do this one, or all, of three things happen:
1) The athlete or client will flex the spine and bring the chest to the knee. At first observation this seems the same, but from a back pain perspective, they could not be more different. Flexion of the lumbar spine is the leading cause of disk degeneration. Those athletes or clients who substitute back motion for hip motion get back pain.
2) The athlete or client will use the TFL and the other ischial hip flexors to flex the hip. In this case the athlete or client will begin to complain of a low-level strain in the TFL. This is a result of overuse of a synergist and will feed into a synergistic dominance of the TFL and further psoas and iliacus dysfunction. This is what we have classically seen in our hockey athletes who utilize a flexed posture.
3) The athlete or client will use the rectus femoris to create hip flexion. This is the mysterious “quad pull” seen in sprinters or on forty-yard dash day in football. In this case the etiology is the same as above, only the culprit is now the rectus femoris, not the TFL. It should be noted, that most “quad pulls” or “quad strains” are limited to the multi-joint rectus femoris. Soreness will generally be near the insertion point of the rectus femoris into the quadriceps at about the mid-point of the thigh. The psoas and iliacus are to the anterior hip as the glute is to the posterior hip. A weak glute max will cause synergistic dominance of the hamstrings and extension of the lumbar spine to compensate for hip extension. This will lead to back pain, anterior hip pain (another Sahrmann point: use of the hamstring as the primary hip extensor changes the lever arm of the femur and can cause anterior capsule pain), and hamstring strains. On the literal opposite side a weak or under-active psoas will cause back pain from flexion rather than extension, TFL strain and rectus femoris strain.
The key to injury prevention and injury rehab is a sound understanding of functional anatomy. We need to stop repeating the mistakes of the past and begin to realize that we all still have a lot to learn from an anatomical and biomechanical perspective. I am amazed at how little anatomy I really know when I look a little deeper.
One of the best things I have read in the past three years is Shirley Sahrmann’s statement, “When a muscle is strained, the first thing to do is look for a weak or underactive synergistic.”
When we are looking at injuries, they do not just happen. They happen for a reason that is governed by the laws of physics and controlled by functional anatomy.